Schooner Inn - <a href

Love this place, wish it would stay open longer in the season!

The view is the best part however I had the worst frozen margarita of my life here. Tasted disgusting and there was ground up bugs or leaves in my drink.

It's okay. I like the view, the live music, and the drinks, but the food is just okay given the price you pay. Granted, all of Fire Island is expensive. That said, the broiled Captain's Platter was kind of bland. I guess I just would have expected a bit more from such a Fire Island hot spot. I'd go back for music and drinks, but probably not for dinner. The char-broiled oysters are worth a try as a snack.

There was practically no cheese on the pizza, sauce tasted cheap, and the crust was dry and thick, even the pepperoni was off

Good food. Great atmosphere.! Fire island prices. Expensive but worth it