Breadsmith - Whitefish Bay

The bread, muffins, dessert, and bear claws at this restaurant are incredibly delicious. The sourdough bread is perfect for toast and is definitely a standout. The staff is very friendly and welcoming. I have been coming here for years and finally decided to write a review. Today, when I was short $0.05, the lady kindly covered it for me, saying "I have you, sweetheart." This place truly feels like home to me.

This bakery is amazing. Everything is fresh and the scent in the air is delightful. We were thrilled with our purchases, especially the chocolate babka and the cinnamon twist pastries. It was our first time trying them and they were so delicious that we came back two days later to buy more for our family and even got one for our neighbor. We wish they also had a cinnamon babka on the menu.

The service at this restaurant is exceptional. The variety of rotating breads and specialties is impressive. Some of my favorite options include the apple cake bread, spinach feta bread, and honey raisin pecan bread. The chocolate chip cookies are also a must-try, especially when they are served warm. Overall, the experience here is amazing.

We love Breadsmith!!!! Not only do they have the best bread, but they are so friendly to the Whitefish Bay community and school children they visit daily for delicious samples. We are so happy to have access to such delicious bread, I have a difficult time to buy bread from any other source. You also have the best email registration! I read them and love the coupons. They are not like other retailers who send emails daily, they send a month and it is worth it! Also love the birthday email. Thanks BREADSMITH!

What happened out there? I'm glad you asked. It was 10:20 on a Saturday when I ordered the cherry-brown. The staff responded, “I’m sorry, they’re not ready.” I could tell they were busy cutting them into sections. Because someone couldn't do their job properly after being open for two hours, the owner missed out on a sale. Great teamwork! Can you imagine having such a lack of professionalism representing your business on a busy day?