Tj's Pizza Cafe - West Milford

Pizza was decent but customer service was not so good. Guy told me the total about 4 times while I was still checking to see if I wanted something else. Felt rushed so didn’t order anything else.

I put an order for the family combo, expecting it to be what I paid for. it turned out that I was released. I asked about 12 bbq wings and I was very disappointed about how they arrived. there's hardly a soda. that was $36 almost $40. Not to mention, I ordered this for delivery, it took to arrive over an hour. unacceptable. Never come back.

This place has the best chicken fingers. The chicken aurora which is basically a vodka chicken parm with asparagus, sun dried tomatoes, and mozzarella balls is amazing. I ordered catering recently and both were a hit.

Love the service.. Pizza/food is made exactly how we like it. Perfection

Yesterday, my wife and I were out driving and just happened to stop at TJ's and each of us got a slice of pizza. Since we moved from Brooklyn to northern New Jersey over 30 years ago, we have not been able to find pizza that we would find in Brooklyn until yesterday: The crust was thin, the cheese was thick and the tomato sauce was perfect. Even though TJ's is over 20 miles from home, we've made a point to modify our future outings to stop there for another slice. WELL DONE TJ'S!!!! BEST PIZZA IN NEW JERSEY!!