The Warwick Inn - West Milford

This was a last minute selection for a Saturday evening dinner. While I thought our entrées were generally pretty tasty, in the end this is basically run-of-the-mill red sauce, Italian at a pretty high price for the area. The calamari appetizer that we shared was most likely frozen, and seemed to be a little well-done. two of us had the chicken Albonetti, which we enjoyed my husband had the short ribs which he enjoyed very much but at $38 it is really fully priced. AlsoWe were told that the entrées came with potatoes and vegetables, but there were no vegetables served. There was another strange issue when we paid the bill, we were five people and one person was paying for three on his credit card and I was paying for two people on my credit card, but they couldn’t figure out how to handle it. The final insult is that they add a 3.5% surcharge if you pay with a credit card. Obviously in this day and age everybody pays with a credit card so it is pretty shady to add this on top of your final dinner bill. If your restaurant is performing that poorly, raise your prices a little bit to cover the cost of credit cards and don’t insult your customers with a surcharge. Sorry to say, but this place seems like it’s on its last legs.

Fantastic service, beautiful atmosphere, delicious food. Service: Dine in Meal type: Lunch Price per person: $20–30 Food: 5 Service: 5 Atmosphere: 5

We had a lovely Valentines dinner at The Warwick Inn. I had the veal martini and he had the chicken francaise...both were absolutely delicious. Portion size was perfect. I read some of the poor reviews about the service. We found the service just fine however, there is a more laid back European vibe. I enjoyed not feeling rushed or bothered throughout our meal. Was a perfect dining experience. Service: Dine in

Meh, the bread wasn't fresh, the seafood was overcooked, asked for linguini served spaghetti, the service was disorganized and the ambiance was nice but the staff loudly arguing with each other made this a lack luster experience overall. Service: Dine in Meal type: Dinner Price per person: $30–50 Food: 3 Service: 3 Atmosphere: 3

I cannot rave enough about the Warwick Inn. Jimmy, Aldo, and his staff are top notch. The food is always delicious, timely, and the staff is wonderful. It has been the favorite place of me and my family for many years. Service: Take out