Salvatore's Old Fashioned Pizzeria

No bathroom facilities. Wheelchair accessibility: None

Food here USE TO be great. But lately the food has been tasteless and sloppy.Before they made your order just like you wanted it, now they do the opposite. I think they changed cooks and I will be changing location

Lake ave location could use some help. Making clients wait longer than necessary. I'm sure you will have some workers who appreciate the

I placed an order on July 4th at 7:30 pm. I didn't realize they closed at 8 or I would have thought twice as to not hold then up. (Didnt realize this till 8:45) Either way the whole experience was a mess.i tied to call 3x at 8:45 and had no answer and rhe shop was closed. At this point I assumed I was not getting my meal. No big deal will get a refund the next day. I then went and got food elsewhere. Nope that is not how it happened. At 9:45/50 they show up at my door apologized sorta. Hot sub was barely warm, cold subs had cheese partially melted from sitting next to the hot sub for to long. None of the subs were made correctly. So I didn't even get what I ordered. I called next day talked with owner/manager. Said didn't know if could do a refund as he had already cashed out for the day but would try. He had offered store credit first but I refused as I had experience with this and it doesn't work or it is a very small amount. This was a 65.00 plus order. I waited a couple of days to see if he could figure it out and then called back when I hadn't heard anything. My response was a curt no refunds and them ended the call. I used to order from here weekly, then became maybe monthly because of all the mistakes. Then it became rare now never again. Customer service sucks. I did make a complaint to the bbb. Will see but sad that it came to that. Used to love that place.

Used to be awesome. Now just meh. Pizza is generally good, but pricey. Last 2 times I ordered a sub, I either got the wrong ingredients or forgotten ingredients. Maybe they just don’t read the order slip as carefully as they used to. Food is really good, but I’d like to get what I ordered. Edit: also, as the prices increase, the portion size seems to be shrinking. What used to be a 14” medium pizza has shrunk to a mere 10”. You’re better off with the super slice. Edit after response: I measured the pizza in the box, it was exactly 10” across.