Mccolley's Irish Pub - Feedback

Was very disappointed with Wick and Beef. Was very apparent that it was not fresh Cut Beef dry and stiff . Sad over$20 with tax and tip. —— just the sandwich

Meh. Place needs a good cleaning and brightening up. It’s dark, outdated, sticky floors. Bathrooms (on slower Monday evening) dirty. Service is great. Food is a...

Had a really good experience here last night. Sat at the bar which we like to do. I do wish the bar was bigger because other times there's no place to sit there...

We've been there twice, and even on a Friday night the wait isn't very long. The wings are great- just the right level of being crispy and evenly coated with sa...

Wife loves the beer selection. They take care of their customers!

My wife and I have made this our favorite place to start or end a night and all in between. Great staff, great food, great music.....especially if Josie (Jody)...

My first time here was for lunch, comfort food on a cold day. The chicken pot pie was delicious!!! Portion size was huge. Will definitely go back..

Food is amazing and staff is even better! Love our neighborhood place

We love McColley’s! We have never been disappointed with our food or the service. The Guinness Beef Stew is my husbands favorite and the French Onion Soup Chick...

The food and service is amazing. I need to come back each week to try the burger of the week. They never disappoint. Worth the trip to Spencerport.

The bar area was a little claustrophobic for me but once we got seated it was very nice. Excellent service and I really enjoyed the fish frey. Good beer selecti...

By far, the best corned beef sandwich I have had. Service great. Price per person: $30–50 Food: 5 Service: 5 Atmosphere: 5 Recommended dishes: Reuben Sandwich

Great place, awesome service. Highly recommend! We definitely go again Price per person: $30–50 Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5 Service: 5 Atmosphere: 5

Great food, delicious food. Huge portions. Our waitress was fabulous. Price per person: $10–20 Food: 5 Service: 5 Atmosphere: 4

Excellent food. Had the fish fry. Delish. Friend had the Rueben. Best I ever tasted.

Absolutely love this place. By far the best restaurant in Spencerport. The food options are unique and always cooked to perfection. The fish fry's are great, es...