Cups 'n Cakes Bakery - Shorewood

We discovered their cheesecake at our favorite coffee place, and is honestly beyond delicious and one of the best I've ever had. I had to then go check them out. It was an hour before closing, so they didn't have a huge selection because their items are fresh and they don't over bake and offer stale product. They have quite a few different cheesecake choices (our favorites are salted caramel and lemon blueberry and every kind we've tried has been outstanding. Their German chocolate cheesecake looks divine, but haven't tried it yet. I can't remember all the varieties, but I know in addition to the 3 I mentioned they have plain, tiramisu, cherry, strawberry and a few others. Their lemon, pecan and apricot bars all look yummy, but I haven't tried them. They also have cupcakes. Ok, I had occasion yesterday to eat a couple cupcakes from a different local place and then eat their lemon blueberry cupcake....theirs blew the competition out of the water! Very flavorful, moist, good balance of frosting, and the taste of the frosting was SO good! The woman who served me (I think she might have been the owner was very friendly and helpful, offering to put things aside in the future if I called ahead since I can't get there until close to closing, and she gave me the cupcake to try (good move because I'm more a cheesecake person but will now absolutely also go back for their cupcakes too! Highly recommend this place.

New owners and they were very nice; however, the macrons were not the same. I did ask if the recipes were the same but the flavor was just not there anymore. They also discontinued a lot of their popular flavors so unicorn is no longer an option. : I hate to say it but I do not plan on returning to this location. Their prices were increased at about 4 bucks a dozen as well. Just not worth it.

Great place to get some cupcakes and cakes. Their German chocolate cheesecake was very moist and perfectly flavorful. Not too sweet either. Definitely the best cheesecake I’ve ever had. We also got the raspberry champagne 6 inch cake and it was a little bit dense and dry but the filling tasted great. Their raspberry champagne cupcakes and their little cheesecakes like the tiramisu and strawberry glazed are also worth trying. The only thing I didn’t love was the vanilla cupcake. The cream tasted very buttery and the cupcake itself tasted more like baking soda or powder rather than vanilla. Could of used some cream inside of the cupcake too. The employees were very friendly and helpful. Definitely would go back!

I had cupcakes made for my daughter's bridal shower. They were the most beautiful cupcakes and tasted absolutely delicious! Everybody at the bridal shower asked where I got them and raved about how beautiful and tasty they were!

I ordered a German chocolate cake this morning for today, and they were able to prepare it for me at the last minute. The cake was absolutely delicious! The young lady who made the cake also assisted me when I picked it up, and she provided excellent customer service!