East Of Chicago Pizza - Shipshewana

We are from the Chicago area and this pizza was delicious and very impressed. The pancrust and ingredients were perfectly cooked and the taste was amazing. This is a little hidden gem. Cudes to this restaurant and staff.

Good, but not the best pizza I ever had: it could have been a little harder on the cheese and less sauce. the bread (Chinese garlic was good. I'll get your food a lot.

We enjoyed the buffet. It was a reasonable price and you could enjoy pop at a very low price compared to most establishments. The lettuce and salad toppings were fresh. The pizza was good. The dessert pizza was amazing! The staff kept a close eye on the buffet as the crowd increased for the supper rush. Our empty plates were promptly removed as we finished. This is a family friendly atmosphere and would work well if dining alone.

Delicious thin crust large veggie pizza! It was Sunday and we arrived late at our hotel and needed dinner — most places were closed, but East of Chicago Pizza was gratefully open. We telephoned in our order and delivered it in about 40 minutes. Yay! Warm pizza with only the perfect amount of tomatoes, peppers, green and black olives, mushrooms, sauce, cheese and delicious crust. Thank you. East of Chicago Pizza. Definitely recommend!

The best deep pizza our family has ever tried. We visited here when we were in Shipshewana and it is now a family lover. The deep plate pizza is so good and the garlic cheese bread is amazing! We also love the Parm Pops with Marinara sauce. Prices are very reasonable and everything is always fresh. They also have a buffet, but we weren't there when it ran. When you go to lunch, they have the perfect size personal pizza called flash pizza. Very recommended! If we lived closer, this would be our way to the pizza place!