Magic's Pizza Shack - Selah

How is this place only a 4.5?! Magic’s is a staple in the community. This place has been serving Selah for years and years. So many people have great memories here, and not much has changed. We still do family dinners here often and birthdays as well. Love the food. And, even under new ownership, the place hasn’t changed, which is great for us. Also, the best bleu cheese dressing and salad bar you’ll find these days. Love Magics! Kid-friendliness: They’ve got a couple games and the tv is on as well. Volume isn’t up high, which is good. Great place for birthdays.

Had our lunch meeting there, 2 servers for the size of our group would have been better, but all in all, it was great. We will continue to do meetings there, like the food and prices were pretty good

I really liked this place years ago but found it less appealing during this visit. The pizza was flaccid and a bit underdone but the pepperoni had a nice kick. The salad bar approached mediocrity. The beer menu was one note with zero dark or amber offerings. Overall these are nice people but the experience left me opting to dine elsewhere.

Got the taco pizza, it was fantastic! The taco meat is delicious, chorizo and beef. The jalapenos are spicy, and the guacamole is fresh. My waitress was nice, the arcade games are a fun touch too. Definitely coming back.

Love the food and Salad Bar!!! Always kind and helpful.