Rosario's Pizzeria - Seaford

Listen Here I'm from Chicago. And I know what good pizza is. First thing I noticed the guy making the pizza is actually Italian, you can tell they put care into making the pizza, not like other pizzeria's that hire the cheapest labor to slap it together. Best regular slices in the entire area for many miles radius.

Nice guy making the pizza. Very new York inside. Very new York slice. 8.0/10 for sure. Our family is on the hunt for the best neighborhood slice this week. Very ny Italian and Ecuadorian family family here and South shore is our new home after living in the Bronx, Brooklyn and Staten. Crispy, no flop, well done. Would love if it was thinner. Little kick to the sauce great cheese balance. High quality New York slice. Exceptional flavor were coming back. Beats out a lot of the neighboring place tenfold. Hidden gem. Pick here before the name recognition places around. ????? Trust and love

So last week I called to place a order for delivery I was asking the menu and what was available and guess what! the old guy who pick the phone is so RUDE he was rushing me a lot and I ending up placing just a regular pepperoni pizza, it’s not the first time buying pizza there but I’m sure that was the last time!!! keep like that and just wait how customers go away!!! ADIOS!!!!

No frills or gimmicks pizza joint, that consistently puts out the best Pies in the massapequa-seaford area. I moved to massapequa over 2 years ago and have honestly tried 20 different places. Ordered from Rosario's on 4 different occasions for my self and guests. Every Time spot on. Great crust, right cook time, nice sauce, generous toppings.

This place has slowly won me over. Fantastic pizza. My new favorite. Great neighborhood local spot.