Creamery Pizza & Ice Cream - Rushford

Stopped here because there isn't much in this neck of the woods... glad I stopped. Had a specialty tap beer that was good. For dinner I ordered the 14 Creamery Special pizza. I like a thin crust with extra cheese, and that is exactly what I got. The only downside is the service was slow. Not sure if that is because they were understaffed for the evening or if that is a norm. It didn't help that my waitress had to man the ice cream counter too. Nice assortment of ice cream flavors but I was stuffed so passed on dessert.

We biked from Lanesboro to Rushford and stopped for lunch at the Creamery. Our pizza was warm and cheesy, much needed after a long bike ride. They have plenty of ice cream flavors to choose from too!

I understand they've recently transitioned to management, which may explain the hiccup we had a week and a half ago two people in our party ordered burgers and the other two ordered pizza, and it took an extremely long time to get the pizza (all while watching folks who arrived after us get their pizzas first maybe they called in their orders ahead? . We had all but the dregs of our fries left before their steaming hot pizzas arrived, and we had eaten slowly. The waitress was very apologetic and explained that there were more pizza orders than grill orders so there was a huge back up in the pizza area. Understandable, but still frustrating, as it would have been nice to have a heads up when we first ordered about how long it would take. But that being said, the food was great, and the ice cream brand they carry is my all time favorite! It was pretty chilly in the dining room area, so we headed outside to heat up to enjoy the ice cream.

The ice cream is fantastic! They have Chocolate Shoppe brand from Wisconsin and it's some of the best ice cream I've ever tasted. Also tried the fish basket and it was good for the price. Didn't expect anything too fancy, so I was satisfied with what I got. Will certainly stop by again whenever we're in Rushford.

The food was disappointing, not worth the price, and the portions were small. Service: Dine-in Meal type: Dinner Price per person: $10–20 Food: 1/5 Service: 2/5 Atmosphere: 1/5 Recommended dish: Bread Sticks.