Cameo Pizza - Put-in-Bay

My friend and I always get Cameo pizza when on the island. The chicken, bacon ranch was my favorite until I tried the sweet fire! It’s the best! Have had the chicken chunks and Mac bites in the past and love them too! Pizzas are loaded with items and the staff is super friendly and fun! Had it delivered this last time and they were very fast getting it to us and the delivery person was so fun! The loaded nachos are great too!

Bugs everywhere! Food cold, paid $60 for cold pizza. I asked the manager to make me fresh pizza and he refused. He took my pizza that I sent back and put it in the lukewarm box where they keep the pizza. Gross and unsanitary. I'm calling the health department because you can get food born illnesses if food isn't kept at the proper temp. I can't risk giving my kids lukewarm food, especially dairy. I'm pretty sure they gave the person behind me the pizza I returned.

It's a shame 0 stars isn't available. Of the many bad things I could say about tonight I'll just leave you with this. We are Out of 2 pizzas and 60 dollars. This pla e has Horrible customer service and I would not recommend to anyone. Except that lady who was behind us. She can eat all the cold pizza she wants.

We ordered a chicken delicacy pizza and I even said we wanted mild sauce (you get to choose your wing sauce). After my fiancé walked back to the hotel we realized they gave us cheese. He went back to tell them and they said oh well and that we had to keep our cheese. Terrible customer service!

This place should shut down. The chicken bites are horrible. Mac and cheese bites soggy. Mozzarella cheese sticks was nasty. Maybe their pizza is good but I won't order from here again. I can't reply to the the owner. I called at 1228 5/19 and was on hold for awhile so it would have been around that time. I was unable to exchange as we already had to wait 50 minutes or more.