Cameo Pizza - Put-in-Bay

Avoid this place if you don't eat pork. They only sell pepperoni slices of pizza. When I asked the manager if I could get a slice with just cheese, he laughed at me and said I would have to order a whole pizza for that. The service was terrible.

The burger was priced at $14, but it tasted like a frozen patty with very little flavor. The fries were a strange combination of overcooked and undercooked. For that price, I expected much better quality. On a positive note, I ordered a large pepperoni pizza for the kids, and that turned out to be great! Overall, though, I have to say the food was disappointing. You really need to improve the quality for the prices you're charging. A good name doesn't matter if the food doesn't taste good. Nonetheless, I appreciate your response and hope you can make some improvements.

The quality of this restaurant is lacking. Chuck E. Cheese offers a better experience than this place does. The food is overpriced and lacks flavor.

My friend and I always get Cameo pizza when on the island. The chicken, bacon ranch was my favorite until I tried the sweet fire! It’s the best! Have had the chicken chunks and Mac bites in the past and love them too! Pizzas are loaded with items and the staff is super friendly and fun! Had it delivered this last time and they were very fast getting it to us and the delivery person was so fun! The loaded nachos are great too!

Bugs everywhere! Food cold, paid $60 for cold pizza. I asked the manager to make me fresh pizza and he refused. He took my pizza that I sent back and put it in the lukewarm box where they keep the pizza. Gross and unsanitary. I'm calling the health department because you can get food born illnesses if food isn't kept at the proper temp. I can't risk giving my kids lukewarm food, especially dairy. I'm pretty sure they gave the person behind me the pizza I returned.