Mama Lucia - Potsdam

I ordered the pick-up from board because they should have. But for some reason, they had customers come to get food. I ordered a little pizza and when I got it, it was the wrong way. It was thin, hard, cold and literally covered with hair. You must literally drop it and put it in a box. It was absolutely disgusting.

The waiters were very nice and attentive but that?s the only good thing I can say. Food was mediocre at best. Alfredo is supposed to be creamy, not taste like dishwater. 9 people and we got our meals 2 at a time. One person didn?t even get theirs until everyone else was almost done. Another group arrived 30 minutes after us and got their food way before we did. They said they would discount the bill but when it showed up there was nothing discounted or removed. Would definitely not recommend.

Absolutely delicious food, with a great atmosphere and excellent service from Nate. This is awesome and authentic Italian food! Be prepared though, this is fine dining and portions are definitely small. Prices reflect the excellent quality of the food. Was it pricey? I think it was worth every delicious penny.

It was ok. I had high expectations based on a previous review. Appetizers and salad were tasty but entrees were bland. Servers were pleasant enough.

The first time my boyfriend has never finished his plate. Mozzarella bread appetizer way over cooked. Medium steak over cooked and over seasoned. My lemon pesto chicken was only lemon with watery sauce. Frozen broccoli, with a 30 dollar meal and 14 dollar drinks. Waiter was friendly though! Never again.