Timoti's Seafood Shak - Ponte Vedra

The food here was terrible. To describe it as merely "bad" would be an understatement. I had intended to take pictures of the dull, unappealing raw poke in the poké bowl and the spoiled avocado found in both the poke bowl and the shrimp rice box. The shrimp had an ocean flavor that matched the unpleasant odor of the inedible poke. I'm sure that consuming either would have made us ill. It's truly embarrassing for a restaurant with seafood in its name to serve such subpar poke and shrimp. It's quite shocking, really. I've never asked for a refund in my time dining out, and I don't plan to start now. However, this establishment should have been aware of the quality of the food they served and should be proactively reaching out to customers. Nocatee would be better off if this place closed its doors.

It's essentially an overpriced seafood fast food joint. My wife enjoyed her salad, but my Po Boy was below average. They even request tips despite only offering counter service.

We are from out of town and visiting family. Stopped by here because we didn't wanna deal with the crowd at dockside. This was great! Shrimp and Mahi were fresh, portions were good. I loved the fries and hushpuppies. The blackened seasoning was on point. Everyone was friendly. Whenever we're in town we will be back!

We absolutely love Timoti's! The food is fantastic, and it's become one of our new favorite spots. We typically order the blackened fish basket, which is amazing, and the chicken fingers are delightful as well! It's a very kid-friendly place with a small playground for children and a spacious patio. Definitely a place you should try!

Yummy fresh fish, shrimp, and lobster rolls! My son says the fries are the best he's had! I really am enjoying the mahi and shrimp tacos (blackened) while my son always orders the fried fresh catch basket. The lobster rolls are very good too. They have a lovely mango iced tea. Casual atmosphere come in your shorts and sandals!!!