Amy's Grill - Pauls Valley

Really bad compared to what it was. It's gone downhill like a snowball headed to....... Cheap meat was cooked in the oven, not grilled. Green beans only...no choice. No crackers for the salad. Won't be going back. Way overpriced!!!!!

This place seemed so promising when we first arrived. It was homey and had a beautiful patio area but I was really disappointed with the food. My pot roast had a reheated taste to it and my husband's hamburger steak was clearly a frozen patty. We both had green beans that were served lukewarm and rubbery. It was not worth the price at around $14 a plate! The owner was talking nearby about how they were struggling with sales and I just wanted to tell her that maybe the food quality and prices were the reason. I just don't understand when people want to take the time to open a restaurant but not take the time to serve good food that gives people a reason to come back.

Wow just got the hamburger steak with onions and mushroom and it was amazing!! You can truely tell they take pride in there food presentation was a 10 and taste was a 15 great job Amy

My wife and I have been here many times and absolutely loved it. They always had great food until this last visit. We called and asked if we could make reservations and I was told we wouldn 't need to. I wanted to because we had a group of 25 people. We gave them a two hour notice, when we arrived nothing was set up (they were not busy). We set the tables up ourselves and waited for service. We ordered our drinks and they informed us they were out of Budwieser, they said they ran out last night? Go buy some before you open!!! They didn 't have all the appetizers because one again they ran out last night? It 's under new ownership and we were handed the old menus. The prices on the menus were different from our bill?? I ordered a 12oz Ribeye and was given a cold 8oz something, damn sure wasn 't the Ribeye I was used to from the Old Amy 's. All I know is they better do something or they be out of business. I 'll go back but it won 't be for awhile!!

Loved the meal, but was given their old menu. We ordered and when the check came they charged us $12 more. Manager would only give 10% off. Bad way to do business. Menu said $19.99 but charged 2$25.99 for each.