Pizza Pub - Oneida

My favorite question about light cooking and cooking it at perfection at home

Have not been to the Ye Olde Pizza Pub in forever and this was the first time at the new location. We ordered takeout and it was perfect. The pizza was delicious just like we remembered. The antipasto was by far one of the best takeout salads we’ve had. Next time we will try dinning in. They still have those long tables and movies playing!

For dinner, we ordered salads and riggies. The salad bar was well-stocked and impeccably clean, offering everything we needed. The self-service drink machine was a delightful feature, allowing us to enjoy as many drinks as we wanted. After we sat down to eat our salads, our riggies arrived in just about five minutes—now that's impressive! The sauce was delicious and not spicy at all. The noodles were cooked perfectly, and the dish was served hot, which was definitely a plus. I also appreciated the garlic bread, which was soft with just the right amount of crispness—just how I like it. The waitress checked in with us twice, and when we finished, paying and exiting the parking lot was seamless. The entire experience was smooth, and the drive home was a comfortable 45 minutes. Thank you, Ye Olde Pizza Pub—we thoroughly enjoyed our dinner!

The food and service are exceptional. Matt and Alicia do a fantastic job ensuring everyone is satisfied. If you haven't been yet, I highly recommend giving it a try!

Overall, I really enjoy Ye Olde Pizza Pub in Sherrill. The pizza is fantastic and the salad bar is impressive, featuring fresh ingredients! I tried the Riggies, Pasta Primavera, and Chicken Broccoli Alfredo, all of which were excellent! However, the wings are a letdown. They're typically small and baked, which isn’t ideal. The sauce is tasty, but there's just not enough of it. Despite the wings, I would definitely recommend Ye Olde Pizza Pub!