David Reay's Modern Diner Tavern

Stop eating for a quick bite after a recommendation from a friend. it was not disappointed, highly recommended. service was exceptional and if you find the perfect wisconsin sitting on the terrace is a must! on the photo is the comfort bowl it is, comfort....and delicious. cannot wait to return to other menu items.

Ate there for the first time today. I had the chicken and waffles with a side of breakfast potatoes. It was good. Only downfall is the waffle itself lacked flavor. Perhaps some vanilla added to the mix could have really amped it up! Otherwise I gotta say I was pleased with my visit. The staff was friendly and attentive, but not overly attentive to where you can't chew your food without being bothered lol. I will definitely be showing up again for another meal!

We had great service. Despite being packed inside and outside, we received our food pretty quickly. The food itself was delicious. The sweet potato fries weren't soggy or over cooked like many places. The steak was also cooked to perfection. The only thing stopping a perfect score was that the restaurant was FREEZING COLD inside. My teeth were almost chattering.

Great atmosphere, clean, employees very attentive. Reason for 3 stars…. My daughter ordered the “Comfort Bowl” off the specialties, bread bowl with mashed potatoes, breaded or grilled chicken, and brown beef? Gravy. Kinda weird and nothing special at all. Came with a side. I ordered the macaroni and cheese and added pulled pork. It had a plain piece of toast cut in four squares with butter…not even garlic bread. I will give this restaurant another try as they have an extensive sandwich and hamburger menu and maybe this first try was just not their best effort. Prices range from $8.00-$15.00.

Atmosphere is fine, it was lovely eating on the patio. Service was fine. Prices a bit high. Decided to add avocado to my BLT. Definitely not worth the $2 upcharge, as you can see in the photo.