Agostini Bakery - Old Forge

Great breads, and good selection of nut and poppy rolls, Italian cookies and pastries, and pies

The premade pizza shells I bought at Price Chopper. They're without a doubt the best I've ever had. I followed the directions on the package adding my own cheese, sauce and toppings. In the oven at 375. Wow, simply amazing. If you make your own pizza at home you have to try the Agostini crusts. Crispy, light, perfect.

The bread here has always been excellent. It's been my understanding this bakery is under new ownership.

There’s a reason why nearly every place in the region that serves pizza (and doesn’t make their own dough) uses their shells. In fact, Agostini’s shells are the main reason why so many bars and restaurants are able to serve quality pizza in the region. They also make it easy to make great pizza at home. Very good and inexpensive.

Owner was unbelievable. Had a coupon through local flavor that expired but value of $15 was good until 2026. She refused to honor it. No indoor dining so we didn't use it. Very unreasonable!!