Oddfellows Ice Cream Co. - Nowatney

Such a good ice cream spot! The flavors were very unique, but they were also delicious.

Holy Cow! $6.49 a scoop for ice cream!!! And not even big scoops. Took my wife, Son, and his two little girls and the bill was over $38.00 for six LITTLE scoops of ice cream. That is never going to happen again. Dairy Joy and about any other place in town is a MUCH better value for your dollar. Of course we don't give a hoot about vegan, so maybe we should have never been in the store to start with???

Wow oh wow. When you step foot into this ice cream shop, you're taken back to childhood. The familiar smell of freshly-made waffle cones envelopes your every sense. There's something so simple but unique about using metal sample spoons but I just loved it. The peppermint crunch is the best peppermint ice cream I've had, and the espresso ice cream with bits of espresso grounds in it is absolutely spectacular. With a dessert store next door and popsicles 3 doors down, it's easy to miss this store, but make sure you keep an eye out and stop by. You won't regret it!

Oddfellows has I screaming, you screaming all of us screaming for ice cream! First off, it is located in the heart of Hyde Park Village, one of Tampa's best hangout spots. The location instantly gives extra points as there is so much to do in Hyde Park and what better way to end the night then with ice cream. Upon walking in, I was warmly (ironic) greeted and offered to sample some literal cold treats. The flavors had fun, unique names that my kids enjoyed while I enjoyed the taste. I found the ice cream to not be overbearingly sweet, in fact, I personally could have went for it being a little sweeter. The prices were a tad bit higher than some of my other local favorites but not so much to knock off points. I sampled a variety of flavors before finally deciding on a two scoop but being honest, you really cannot go wrong with any flavor you choose. All are unique enough where you're sure to leave satisfied while not feeling weighed down by the typical richness you would find in these flavor combinations. After you enjoy one of the many spectacular restaurants in the village or if you're just hanging out in the area, be sure to stop here to scream for some ice cream!

Reece and Becca were great. They greeted my wife and I with smiles and an engaging back and forth since we were the only ones on line. I appreciate their patience and recommendations. We will be back because of their friendliness!