Vitucci's Pizza - New Berlin

Since moving out of Illinois, finding a good pizza place has been impossible. Luckily, I happened to try this little pizzeria and now I'm HOOKED! You can tell they put all their funds back into the food. The quality is outstanding! Don't let the look of the building turn you away from this hidden gem!

Almost all pizza in Wisconsin is terrible, serving bland and disgusting garbage and everyone likes it because they don't know any better. But this Vituccis place is one of the better ones I've found in the Milwaukee area. The pizza is actually flavorful and not bland junk like so many other places. It's a little bit of a drive but it's way better than any of the places in Milwaukee.

Would have given zero stars if allowed. This is a carry out only and I cannot give stars for food or anything thing else. When I arrived to pickup my order I was told someone before me got my order. They offered to make new if I would wait for 40 minutes. Won't be back. Balistreris on 68th or Marty's on Bluemound will be the go to. First and last timer.

Browsed through Yelp for pizza and Vitucci's was up on my list. Very solid pizza but the calzone is what was spectacular. Very good food satisfied with what I got for the price.

Really love the thin crispy crusty. I do wish the sauce was a bit spicier but it won't stop me from ordering it again! The staff is always super friendly and the prices are very reasonable!