Gotham Bagels - Feedback

Crazy busy nice staff food is ok way to high energy for me .. Great for college kids

It’s good, but it seems like they have execution problems. Why does it take 45 minutes to make a lox bagel? They were somewhat busy, but it’s pretty frustrating...

Went on a Saturday morning. Ordered bacon egg and cheese on a plain bagel with spicy ketchup and a coffee. Total price $12 and change. $8.50 for the sandwich an...

The food? Incredible. It takes a bit for them to craft a sandwich. They 're a little pricey. The owner or manager is a little loud with his bellowing voice. The...

Food was good but the service was a bit slow and impersonal

I went to buy Bagels today not to realize that they only had an online order system. My order quickly placed in about 2 minutes. Less than 2 minutes later I got...

Bagels are chewing and delicious. Cream cheese flavor selection is full of savory choices. Order the app to compensate for waiting time. The banana bread was re...

I love her Bialys and her bagels. The taste of the bagels calls memories of the NYC Bagels...but he does not import the water. And I LOVE they're delivering. Th...

The Bagels themselves are still good enough for the Middle West, but the New York Service-Schtick runs thin when your food is not available until an hour after...

Sandwiches are always great but since the pandemic and closing of the main dining room, other service has suffered. I've always loved their Cream of Wild Mushro...

The bagels themselves are still good enough for the midwest, but the owner's New York service schtick runs thin when your food isn't available until an hour aft...

Sandwiches are always great but since the pandemic and closing of the main dining room, other service has suffered. I've always loved their Cream of Wild Mushro...

I absolutely love their Bialys and bagels! The taste of the bagels reminds me of the ones from NYC—though they don’t import the water, which is a fun fact. I al...

I went to buy bagels today and didn’t realize they only had an online ordering system. I quickly placed my order in about two minutes. Less than two minutes lat...

The bagels here are chewy and delicious, with a wide variety of savory cream cheese flavors to choose from. To minimize your wait time, it's best to order ahead...

I’ve never encountered such a diverse selection of bagel sandwich options. I ordered the Brighton Beach, and it was absolutely delicious! The layers were simply...

Without a doubt, the BEST bagels in Madison. I highly recommend their Piled High Pastrami bagel sandwich—it's truly life-changing!

This charming old-fashioned bagel shop near the Madison Capitol is a great spot for anyone looking to experience a wide variety of cream cheese flavors. The fri...