Olde Schoolhouse Cafe Phone Number, Reservations, Reviews

Probably some of the best pizza I’ve ever had. All of the dollar bills on the ceiling were fun to read. The pizza crust was bubbly and cooked to perfection. The wait was about 30 minutes but it was also busy. Totally fine because the taste of the pizza was so worth it!

I ordered two pizzas (veggie and pepperoni) and two salads for takeout, and my total was a shocking $76. When I asked about the outrageous price, I was told it included a 20% “gratuity.” This is nothing but a sneaky “takeout fee.” A gratuity is supposed to be something given voluntarily or beyond obligation, usually as a tip for service. Adding a mandatory gratuity for takeout is deceptive and unfair. This place is clearly trying to rip off its customers.

Was the wait long... yes... but was it absolutely delicious and huge portion sizes... sure was. Come in, order food, have a drink and play the free pool and shuffle board. The food won't take as long if you are having fun. We came to the area from AZ, and my family came from NM, it was our first time visiting the Olde Schoolhouse. We were welcomed and treated nicely by Ben and had a great night. In fact, we took a pizza home with us all the way to AZ because it was so good.

Wonderful atmosphere and the owner is a smoking hot babe!

We just got done with 5 hour hike up a mountain and were desperate for food after living off of MREs for a couple days. All the places near the trailhead were closing down by the time we got in town and we called this place and they offered to make food and hold it for us and warm it up when we got there even though we would be getting there after the kitchen closed. The food was beyond amazing and so was the service. Oh when they mean their calzones are huge, they mean it. It’s damn near a medium size pizza flipped in half.