Fratello's Pizza Company - Horseheads

We ordered a sheet pizza and the dough was raw and gave us all stomach aches. When I called to tell them the dough was raw they said I needed to order it well done and refused to give me anther pizza even though I offered to return 95%of the raw pizza.. So rude I'll never order a pizza or anything from them again EVER...

I am always very pleased with my orders from this place.

Undercooked delivered pizza. This pizza place used to be very good. I am not sure what has changed, but very disappointed and will go elsewhere from now on.

I can't believe they charge $2.99 for each topping. A dollar's worth of chicken, maybe $7.50 for the basic beef? Honestly, for the broccoli, they shouldn't have even charged for the 18 pieces—it's just ridiculous. The dough was barely cooked, almost raw in the middle, and the cheese wasn’t even melted. The sauce was off as well. I'm really disappointed. This was terrible, and I won't be ordering again.

We decided to try this pizza place since we're new to the area, and I'm so glad we did. The food was outstanding! The pizza was enormous, though I found it a bit saucy for my personal preference. The wings were absolutely fantastic—especially the mild boneless wings and garlic knots, which we couldn’t get enough of. Everything was bursting with flavor. The garlic parmesan wings were delicious, but I think they could use just a pinch more salt. Overall, we had a great experience and will definitely be ordering from here again!