Anthony's Of Guilford

Anthony's should close up shop. Used to be great. Ordered a spinach and mozz stuffed bread and it was tasteless. No seasoning.

Bad customer service! I had an extremely frustrating experience last week with Anthony's takeout. At 3:30pm, I placed (and paid for) an online order of 3 stuffed breads to take to an event that started at 6pm. I showed up at the time I designated on the order form (5:30) and was told (very rudely, I might add) that they cancelled the order at 5pm because they don't do same day stuffed bread orders. As if I'm supposed to know that--I was, after all, able to order and pay. They took no responsibility--blaming the company that facilitates their online order process. In fact, the woman behind the cash register and the chef argued with me, as if it was my fault. She even said their regular customers knew. Well, I was a first time customer and that will be my last time there. As a small business owner, I know and appreciate the value of taking care of customers. They did nothing. Thank goodness Carpanzano's down the road had a case full of stuffed breads. Of course I was late to my event because I had to make another stop and take the time to heat up the breads...Honestly, if they had treated me better, I would not be writing this review, but their attitude towards me as a customer was inexcusable.

Boy do these people know how to cook. We stopped here for the first time ever so we tried a few different things on the menu. We always like to order a pizza when trying a new Italian restaurant and it was excellent. Words can't describe the delicious calzone we had. The calzone we ordered had sausage in it . The crust of the calzone was thin and crispy and the filling was just the right amount of ricotta and mozzarella, perfectly balanced and sausage in every bite. Their sausage is homemade and out of this world. I also order the shrimp florentine. The shrimp were delicately fried with I think an egg batter coating that was light and very tasty and the sauce and spinach was perfect. Good size portion and even better the next day. Last but not least, the pepperoni bread. Well, I've had many different stuffed breads from numerous restaurants but this one tops them all. Again, perfect balance of meat and cheese, crispy thin crust and delicious ingredients. If you haven't stopped here to grab dinner for your family then you are missing out on excellent quality food. My tastebuds don't lie so give Anthony's of Guilford a try.

We are blessed with plenty of solid pizza options around here. Anthony's is clearly one of them, and is consistent and the staff are always friendly and efficient. It feels like a place that comes from family pride. And unlike the place down the road (that's also very good pizza), you don't have to wait an hour and a half.

Last time my family and i went here was over 10 years ago. we stopped going as they were constantly over salting the food, so we decided to give them another try as it?s been a while since our last visit. food was fine, there was nothing wrong with it, but it definitely wasn?t good enough to wait an hour for. service was painfully slow, but they definitely gave enough food. it just shouldn?t take an hour to get us our food when all we ordered was simple pasta dishes and a plain mozz pizza.