Goodfellas Pizzeria Mill Street

Pizza was absolutely amazing we got 5 different ones and 6 breadsticks and all was great. Wish we had one close to us back home!!!

The pizza is the best in Lexington, no matter what Dave Portnoy @stoolpresidente and his legion of mouth breathing, knuckle dragging, window licking, twitter lemmings say. HIGHLY RECOMMEND.

Pizza had to be warmed up and the breadsticks were very dry. 1 slice of pizza and 1 breadstick was $10 smh

This review isn’t food related, but the manager Joe provided the worst customer service I’ve ever experienced. We called to ask about including flyers for their store in our move in packets for our housing complex (aka free marketing for them). As we were speaking, he said “I’m gonna stop you right there. I have a line out the door. It’s 12:20 pm why would you call at this time???” and hung up. This was such an unprofessional way to handle a phone call, especially for a manager. If they were so busy, he could’ve easily said “Hey we’re really busy right now, do you mind calling back at a different time?”. Overall disappointed in the lack of customer service skills and would not recommend interacting with Joe to anyone.

Amazing pizza, amazing price, weekend atmosphere gives New York or Beale Street or something similar. Can be a great place to run into people Parking: Need to park on the street somewhere within walking distance. After a certain time, parking is free but I’m not exactly sure what time. I know if it’s nighttime, downtown street parking is free. Kid-friendliness: Not a lot of space once you get inside, so if your kid likes to bounce off walls, maybe don’t bring them inside? ? Wheelchair accessibility: Probably not enough room for a wheelchair to fit through the door, but you could try!