Salvatore's Tomato Pies - Greshamville

Their Da Beets pizza was exceptional! Highly recommend.

Really high quality but can be difficult to get in at times. Fig and bacon pizza was excellent. One gripe is that they have resy listed in Google but it doesn't appear to currently actually accept reservations.

I've been to three of their stores. Every one is uniquely different with great, very personable service Enjoy

Can’t beat $12 one topping pies on Tuesdays! We literally get this 3-4x a month. Love their bacon, fresh jalapeño, Gorgonzola, pepperoni, or fig as the topping

This is the only place in Madison that I choose to order from if I have a craving for a pizza-like thing (these are definitely tomato pies, and some don't even have tomato sauce). They're are spectacular hipster creations that I couldn't even dream of. Who thinks of putting 4 different mushrooms on a pizza? The ingredients are to die for and they make even a basic creation mouth-watering. They are fantastic with allergies/diet restrictions and I always feel comfortable ordering here. They're a little expensive, so I won't order this for a party, but I will definitely order a whole pie for myself.