Catfish Willy's Seafood Comfort Cuisine

Restaurant Review Catfish Willy's Evansville. This is my comment I posted to their site which I am sure will be deleted as soon as they see it. Avoid their All You Can Eat Catfish Special!! Our party consisted of 4 people, my wife, brother in law, sister in law and myself. Arrival 5:15pm Saturday July 29, the place had several guest but was not crowded and no wait seating was available. All 4 of us ordered the all you can eat catfish special, a bit pricey at $19.99 each but hey it was all you can eat catfish and sides. After 30 minute wait on food our first round consisted of two slivers of fish looks like they had cut a standard size fillet in at least 3 if not 4 pieces and one side. Their side choices for their all you can eat are fries, hush puppies, and cold slaw. You can switch sides between orders but you can only get one at a time. So our first serving was far from a standard catfish dinner, but it is all you can eat, right? So I asked the waitress to put in our next order immediately since the initial order took so long which she did. Needless to say all four of us finished our meager first serving in less that 5 minutes, and then waited 20 minutes for our second order of fish to arrive, the same slim servings as the first but with no sides. We were informed we had to put in orders for fish and sides separately. We put in another order for fish immediately. We finished our second order of fish long before or second order of sides appeared and finished these long before our third order of fish appeared. The pattern continues for a full two hours with me complaining to the waitress all the while before our friends said they had had enough and were ready to leave. All total we received less food than a standard fish dinner at Cheddars or Sam's Southern Eatery. No offer to reduce bill, no manager to talk to, and no comment cards. We will not be back!!

Me and my fiancé went there for date night and had the most amazing meal ever. I love seafood but this is definitely the best I’ve had in Evansville. Our server, Nick had such and amazing vibe. He is a really cool person and made the experience 10 times better. Plus the sharks and birds hanging from the ceiling was super cool too. Definitely coming again and you should go too!

Had a fantastic dinner!! Ryan gave great service kept us laughing!!I got to bring my sister for her first time and Ryan made sure she found something she could eat (non-spicy).Food: 5/5

First time visiting and the food was amazing. I had the shrimp pasta and coconut shrimp. Ryan waited on us and he was so funny and engaging.Food: 5/5

Wake up Evansville you have a true jewel here every bit as good as the red clawed place. The food is delicious and the portions are large. Excellent service the atmosphere could use some refinement but who cares the food is great.Parking: Ample parking even during busy times.Wheelchair accessibility: Great entry ramp not a step to negotiate. Tables are wheelchair accessible.