Brooklyn Pizza - Erie

Fantastic pizza and wings! While it may be a bit on the expensive side, I truly believe it’s the best in Erie, and they serve some of the largest portions you'll find. If you usually order a large at other restaurants, a medium here will be more than enough. Plus, expect your food to arrive about 5-10 minutes earlier than the estimated delivery time. Super fast service!

Wonderful pizza! They offer massive 18-inch thin crust New York-style pies. The white pizza is fantastic, while the red pizza is delicious but a bit on the sweet side. The wood-fired flavor is quite subtle. The specialty topping combinations are thoughtfully selected. However, the true highlight of this Brooklyn pizza experience is definitely the crust. Unlike some places in Erie that still rely on pre-made crusts, here the crust is an integral part of the pizza, and Brooklyn understands that well. It's great that there are two locations in the southern and western suburbs—I’m hoping for one to open in the central city soon!

The staff is warm and welcoming, and the service is outstanding. I highly recommend this pizzeria. The manager truly understands pizza. Thank you to everyone at Brooklyn Pizza for providing such a wonderful experience!

These guys do an awesome job. Lots of options, the ingredients are great and the place is clean. Everyone was friendly when I went in to pick up. The slices are huge, even on the medium. But the crust isn't bready like some places. You actually get what you pay for. I strongly recommend their jalapeno popper pizza. It's amazing.

Erie is a difficult city to get good pizza in. Brooklyn's pizza and wings are both excellent, but a little on the pricey side. A few times when they were busy they have given us the wrong sauce on our wings or the wrong pizza which considering the price was too much to botch, so check your order before you leave.