Los Magueyes Crystal River

I love their food and they'd been really great, but the last two times I've ordered take out and been very specific on what I want (and paid extra for it ... ie extra sour cream, no guac, cheese sauce on the side because I eat it for 2 meals, etc) they have messed it up. I understand its a lot to ask but I tip 20% on take out, and its Like Majorly messed up. It's super frustrating to pay extra for stuff and then it not be right. I mean ridiculously not right. AND I watched her write down the order. And bc it's all double knotted to go when they sit it there... so while I should have checked the bag, Ive never had this bad of an issue and I'd have to rip the bag open bc of the knot. So annoyed rn.

One of my favorite places to eat Mexican food when I’m in the area. The food is always great and very authentic. The waitress, Celina was so adorable and on top of everything, making sure we had everything we needed. Caitlin wait to come back. I highly recommend trying this place out.

Dirty restaurant with cobwebs in light over table, dust bunnies crawling up wall from floor vent next to table, ripped seats all over restaurant and dirty glasses with chipped plate. The food was OK, the best part was the fresh salsa. Margarita was mediocre. I'm not sure how this place has such a good rating. Service was fast, but then she never checked on us again until I was holding my card ready to leave. We will not be back, but I think the county inspector should pay a visit!

Have been to Los Magueyes on Gulf to Lake Highway several times, but always for lunch. Our lunches there in the past were good. Our adult son was visiting so we went for dinner for the first time. It was a Monday night about 6 pm and the place was very crowded. First thing we noticed was the disrepair of the porch and railings outside rotted and falling apart. The booth we were given had the seat held together with massive quantities of duct tape. Food took a long time to arrive and all three of our orders didn't arrive at the same time. Two orders were good but my Camerones Maguey (shrimp with spinach, onions and broccoli) was just awful. I have had this a number of times at lunch and it was good in the past. The shrimp was all burned on one side and the chef turned that side down in an effort to hide it. The onions were burned black and whole thing was swimming in grease instead of the tasty sauce its supposed to have. I tried to eat some because mine was the last entree out and the others' food was getting cold waiting for me. Finally complained and they offered to make a new one but, by that time, I was so turned off and the others had finished their food so I declined. They did take the entree off the bill but that didn't make up for a really bad dinner experience. Stopped at the restroom before leaving and it was filthy. Had indigestion all night afterwards. Such a shame. We liked this restaurant but it is now so run down and dirty and, after this meal, we will not be back.

We had a great meal here today and the service was exceptional… The food was good. I think the steak in the fajitas could’ve been undercooked a little bit more. It was a little tough, and they really need to do something with the booth chairs as they are covered in electrical tape on some of them. We will definitely be back though. !!! Good !!!