Sarefino's At North Market - Columbus

I had heard great things about the pizza at this place, so I was eager to try it during my stay at the Hampton Inn. Not wanting to drive and frustrated that Grubhub said Sarefinos was closed, I decided to check out the nearby MarketNorth pavilion that I heard featured various vendors. I grabbed a slice of pizza, and it was AMAZING. I couldn’t resist having a second piece... and it was just as AMAZING. As I was leaving, I finally noticed the sign that said Sarefinos Pizza. It truly lived up to the hype! The pizza is NY-style thin, with a wonderful crunch on the bottom. The sauce is perfectly balanced—subtle and not overwhelming—making it just fantastic overall! If you’re staying at the Hampton Inn, definitely make your way across the street to what looks like a grocery store, head to the back wall, and look for the pizza vendor. You won’t be disappointed!

This restaurant offers excellent New York-style pizza located within the North Market in downtown Columbus. It can be a bit tricky to access, but the experience is definitely worth it. They also serve other Italian dishes, which I haven't had the opportunity to sample yet. I would rate the pizza a remarkable 4.8 out of 5.

You won't find a closer match to New York pizza than Sarefino's! I've never encountered any problems with the customer service or the food. It's honestly the best pizza I've ever had outside of Manhattan. I just wish there were a location nearer to Dublin, but the drive downtown is definitely worth it!