Noah's Pizza And Grill - Coats

The food at Noah's was unexpectedly delightful, proving the old adage that you shouldn't judge a book by its cover. My wife and I initially planned to order takeout pizza, but we ended up dining in. She chose the lasagna, which was quite flavorful, though it had a touch too much oregano and sauce for her taste. The pizza was also fantastic, featuring high-quality cheese and a wonderful balance of flavors. The service was outstanding, with attentive staff and a cozy atmosphere that made us feel right at home.

I wouldn't recommend ordering the Philly sandwich; it has very little meat and way too much mayo. I won't be getting this again.

I had the worst experience with customer service at this restaurant. I placed an order for my daughter's birthday dinner, and unfortunately, it was messed up. They forgot our fries and added cheese to the garlic knots. The rude manager insisted that we had requested no Parmesan, but they had actually used feta cheese. It's frustrating when the saying "the customer is always right" clearly doesn't apply here. There were no ingredients listed on the order form, so it was impossible for us to know they would use feta instead of Parmesan, which is common in most places. The manager didn’t apologize or offer to make things right—he simply said he would send out the fries, which never arrived. Our bill came to $62, with the fries costing over $10. I tried calling today, since they're closed on Sundays, and was informed that they couldn't issue a refund for the missing item. It was an incredibly disappointing experience.

I really enjoy dining at this restaurant. My family discovered it while visiting Campbell University, and now our children, who are 4 and 11 years old, absolutely love eating here and interacting with the staff. We feel like part of the family and truly appreciate the great service and delicious food.

Additionally, there was no clear indication of ingredients on the order form, which added to our confusion about the missing parmesan instead of feta. The manager never offered an apology, despite the issues. He mentioned he would send out fries, but they never arrived. Our total bill was $62, and the fries were over $10. When I called today to address the issue, I was told they can’t issue refunds on specific items. Overall, it was a frustrating experience.