Tommy's Pizza - Byesville

Tommy's Pizza is my wife's absolute favorite pizza place—no contest! We usually order a half tray with light sauce, and it always turns out fantastic. Occasionally, we also get the cheesy bread, and it's equally delicious! Randy, Debbie, Amanda, Andrea, and Emily are always incredibly friendly when we stop by for a bite to eat. When Debbie is selling her brownies, be sure to grab one; you won't regret it! Plus, Amanda often has special pizza combinations for a limited time... I really hope they bring back the pickle pizza!

This restaurant excels at providing an exceptional dining experience! My takeout dinner was a pleasure, and the pricing was just right. I would give the food a perfect score of 5 out of 5. The pepperoni pizza was absolutely superb—definitely a dish you shouldn’t miss! The service was outstanding as well, deserving a strong 5 out of 5, and the overall atmosphere, even while enjoying my meal at home, was fantastic. I highly recommend this place!

When the day finally came and we called to place our order, Amanda was extremely rude. She insisted that we should have called ahead (which we did, twice) and then stated that it would take over an hour to be ready instead of the promised 20-30 minutes. When I arrived to pick up the order, Amanda was rude once again. To my disbelief, she even spoke disrespectfully about me to her coworkers while I was right there. I stayed calm, paid the $120 for the food, and left. I truly hope the owner sees this and addresses the situation because Amanda is negatively impacting this business. Many of us have decided we will no longer be customers unless changes are made.

Every time I visit, I experience the best service and pizza in town! Food: 5/5, Service: 5/5, Atmosphere: 5/5.

Excellent wings and pizza. New York style is huge. Meal type: Dinner Price per person: $30–50 Food: 5 Service: 5 Atmosphere: 5