Paulie Gee's Slice Shop - Brooklyn

Slices were solid, what you expect from a really good pizzeria. I wasn't a fan of hot honey on the hellboy pizzas. Might be a matter of personal taste.Squares are just so much better, though. The Freddy Prince pizza was pretty good. The sesame crust was super nice and crunchy.However, the sauce and cheese distribution on my pizza was pretty awful. I got a corner slice that was undersauced, making the slice 50% crust. Kind of a lame experience, but I assume this isn't a normal occurrence given the pictures and what I saw in the store. A little unlucky but still enjoyable.

Retro and nostalgic with everything about the food and beverage being modern and hip. This is consistently the best pizza in the city for lactose intolerant and/or vegan diets. Fantastic cheese toppings presented on what I consider a case study in New York style, slice shop crust. You can wash everything down with local beers like other half green city IPA I highly recommend it ?Dietary restrictions: Vegan cheese and Vegan toppings

Paulie Gee's Slice Shop is a true gem in the neighborhood, and it has quickly become my personal favorite spot for a classic on-the-go slice. From the first bite, I was impressed by the exceptional quality and flavor of their pizza.The standout feature of their pepperoni slice is the crust. It strikes a perfect balance, delivering a satisfying crunch while still being delightfully tender on the inside. The texture of the dough is a testament to the careful craftsmanship that goes into each slice. Topped with a generous amount of cheese, the pizza is prepared with precision, ensuring that every bite is a burst of cheesy goodness.One of the joys of enjoying a slice is the experience of holding it in your hands, and Paulie Gee's makes this part of the meal delightful. The slice is easy to hold and devour, adding to the overall satisfaction of the dining experience.I also tried the Hellboy Squared. This Sicilian-style pizza is a solid choice, made even more satisfying by the drizzle of Mike's Hot Honey. The combination of sweet and spicy flavors is a winning one, and it elevates the pizza to another level of deliciousness. I particularly appreciated the attention to detail in lining the bottom of the square with sesame seeds, which added a delightful crunch and depth of flavor.Beyond the outstanding pizza, Paulie Gee's Slice Shop offers cool vibes that make it an ideal place to enjoy a meal. The welcoming atmosphere and friendly service only enhance the overall experience.

Stumbled upon this place as I was walking and was glad I had a slice..had the hellboy because that was the one with the hot honey on it and the sound of it was so unique and the taste was great too. Also, tried a slice of vegan sausage pizza which was so good as well. Couldn't really say it was vegan as it still had the traditional pizza taste. Will definitely try again when I am around this neighborhood

The Hellboy Squared is delicious. Light, thick, airy dough fully covered in sesame at the bottom. Crunchy from end to end. Rich, jammy tomato sauce. Crispy, charred pepperoni cups that hold onto the hot honey. Paulie Gee’s breathed new life into the square slice genre and fully made it their own thing.Vegetarian options: Vegan pizza available