Nasto's Ice Cream Co. Old World Desserts

This was my first time visiting this shop, and I’m really glad my friend recommended it. The ice cream was delightful! I chose the chocolate chip cookie dough flavor, which combines two of my favorites. It was rich in flavor without being overly sweet. They offered a variety of flavors, and you can sample them before making a purchase. You can enjoy your ice cream at the outdoor seating in front of the store. I will definitely be returning!

The best tres leches cake in the world! I always bring it to every occasion, and people can't stop talking about how amazing it is! I'm a lifelong customer.

I might be a bit partial since I grew up in this neighborhood, but I truly believe I haven't found better ice cream anywhere else. If you've tried Tartufo, Sorbet, or Gelato at a restaurant in the tri-state area, there's a good chance it came from Nasto's. If you find yourself in Newark, you definitely need to make a stop here. You can select any flavor of ice cream they have on display, and they'll pack a pint for you to take home. Their birthday cakes are always popular at parties, but keep in mind they contain nuts in the center, so be cautious if anyone has allergies. Personally, my favorite is the Oreo cookie milkshake!

I absolutely love the variety of flavors available, especially the fruity options. We sampled the pineapple ice cream and the graham slam, and both were exceptional. The pineapple ice cream was truly unique—intensely flavorful with a wonderful balance of creamy smoothness and pineapple chunks. It struck the perfect blend of subtlety and sweetness. The graham slam brought back memories of enjoying s'mores. The graham flavor had a lovely toasty, cinnamon note that was just right—not overpowering at all. The addition of chocolate crunch pieces was the perfect finishing touch. I would definitely rate this place a perfect 10 out of 10!

Amazing ice cream! The place is spotless, the service is fast, and the staff is very friendly! There's an extensive variety to choose from! Every flavor is made on-site with great care, and the quality is outstanding! This place is definitely a hidden gem! I highly recommend it!