Carmine's - Broad Channel

Sooo good! Best lasagna we've ever had. We even tried to go back another night, but unfortunately they couldn't seat us because we didn't have reservations. I would advise to make a reservation if you would like to eat here. Its worth it!

Good restaurant serving family style meals. A lot of food for just two people but service eas great and reasonable price

Be prepared to wait 30-60 minutes during peak times, even with reservations. Huge portions that are great for sharing/family style. Unfortunately our pasta and meatballs were not good. The meatballs were mushy and tasted like pure Parmesan and Italian seasonings. The meats were lost. There wasn't enough sauce for the pasta under the meatballs. The chicken Marsala was good and so was the bread. Our server, Eggbert, was very energetic and personable, but we never saw him again after placing our order. We asked a couple of people for a little more sauce for the pasta, but didn't get it. The gentleman that packed our food to go did bring a side of sauce to take with us. Perhaps this was a one off bad experience. Maybe we'll try a different location in the future.

The food here is outstanding! All dishes are served family style. My wife and I got a Caesar salad and Eggplant Parmigiana to split both of them. We literally ate only 1/3 of each. Each of the items were enough to feed 4-6 adults.

Must go if you’re in TimeSquare. Expensive but worth it.