Schultzy's - BAYVILLE

We wandered in on a beautiful fall Sunday for brunch. Two years ago it was a small, too-busy diner- it is now a chic, cozy upscale restaurant with surprisingly reasonable prices for truly beautiful food, a cut above. I had the shrimp and grits special- shrimp were grilled in olive oil and Old Bay, on a bed of sinfully saucy light Gouda cheesy grits, just superb. My husband had French Toast, elegantly served with fresh fruit, and the coffee was also flavorful. We didn't have drinks this time but they are available. At noon a talented guitarist/singer enhanced the already pleasant, mellow vibe. The owner stopped to chat with each table and service was attentive and friendly. We will be back.

Great food and service. Our friends want to know when we can go back. Freshest seafood, lobsters and more!

The dinning area is just the right size to allow the staff to be attentive. There was plenty of available parking for a short walk on spacious sidewalks. The staff members were upbeat and helpful for an out of towner. The quality was that of a high end restaurant with a lower key feel. The food was priced reasonably with generous portions for fresh seafood.The small town feel made us feel right at home with the owner/operator Jimmy and his family like staff. We visited on a Saturday when we got in and enjoyed it so much we went back on Monday evening. We had a father daughter wait staff for lunch on Saturday and were super impressed with how engaged and attentive the younger members were. Please don’t take our word for it, try it for yourself!

First time there and it was delightful. Cute Barroom with large Bar, High top and regular tables, great service and the food was delicious. The place is small but comfortable, sound moderate. Large selection at raw bar as well as a nice offering of fresh fish. Super casual, perfect for Bayville parking a challenge but you'll fine one.

We've been waiting to try Schultzy's for awhile now and I'm happy we finally have last night. This is an amazing gem nestled in Bayville just over the bridge. The people and the service are just amazing and fantastic. The cold beer freezer cold that is are kick ass. We had the baked clams, and Brussels sprout Kale salad just delicious. The baked clams are outrageously good the salad too. My wife had the crabmeat stuff shrimp and I had the crabmeat stuffed lobster it was a pound and a half both just outstanding and delicious cooked to perfection.The place is just fantastic you'd be remiss if you didn't have a meal here. This is another one of our favorite Oyster Bay joints that we will be eating at the rest of our lives. We love our home in Oyster Bay and great restaurants like this.